Sometimes an idea just can’t quit you; it just knock and knocks until you let it in. Charles Darwin, famously, believed he’d had a “eureka” moment in 1938, but in fact he’d scribbled the components of his theory of evolution into his notebooks months prior.
Answering the question “How do we measure if an organization is democratic or not?” is one idea I haven't been able to push away (see previous posts). It has worked its way into our research for the Purpose Trust Ownership Network and the Skoll Centre report on organizational purpose, power, and profit we launched last week.
It's also why I'm attending a conference tomorrow on worker voice in frontier AI labs. The event is being put on by the Institute for Ethics in AI at Oxford and Dr. Isabelle Ferreras, the rockstar academic driving the Spanish government to take economic democracy seriously. That Spanish report offers a Corporate Democratic Development Index with two scales:
Voice: The share of board-level voting rights held by workers
Ownership: the percent owned by workers
In our Skoll Centre report on organizational purpose, power, and profit, we offer just one (less nuanced) “ladder” of how organisations share decision-making power, with examples:
But in a working paper with Michael Palmieri and Tim Randall, we argue that the most useful way to measure organisational democracy might come from the V-Dem Institute’s five-scale index measuring how democratic countries are, plus one additional scale. (American readers, I hate to bear the news that V-Dem downgraded us from a “liberal democracy” to an “electoral democracy” last year).
And in another working paper with Saurabh Lall and supported by the Purpose Trust Ownership Network, we’ll float a trial balloon of that six-scale index of organizational democracy (O-Dem?), asking leaders to rate their agreement with the following:
“Employees regularly elect representatives to the bodies that govern this organization, with multiple candidates and free advocacy.” ← Built from V-Dem’s electoral democracy index; this maps onto the Spanish report’s Voice scale.
“Employees have formal, enforceable protections that constrain managerial authority, including grievance processes and rules that apply equally to managers and employees.” ← From V-Dem’s liberal democracy index.
“Most employees participate directly (as opposed to via a representative) in decisions affecting their team, unit, or the organization as a whole.” ← From V-Dem’s participatory democracy index.
“Major decisions are typically preceded by structured discussion in which dissenting views are heard, reasoned justifications are offered, and the good of the organization motivates discussion.” ← From V-Dem’s deliberative democracy index.
“All employees enjoy similar protections, make roughly the same amount of money; and contribute more or less equally to decision-making.” ← From V-Dem’s egalitarian democracy index; this maps onto the Spanish report’s Ownership scale.
“We have regular training for our employees to understand and be able to participate in organizational decision-making, including financial and strategic decisions.” ← Our own first cut at an epistemic democracy index.
As I head to the Palace of Westminster tomorrow, I’ll be listening for what different speakers and attendees mean when they say “democracy.” I’ll let you readers know (within Chatham House rules) what I hear.
And you can also bet I’ll be listening for any hint others are also calling for more work on how we might do politics with autonomous AI agents once they slip containment. Happy weekend!



